Timesheet fraud: what it looks like and how to prevent it

Timesheet fraud is claiming pay for time that was not worked. Sometimes it is deliberate, like clocking in for a friend who is running late. More often it starts small: a lunch that ran long, a start time rounded in your own favor, a Friday filled in from memory.

This article covers the forms it takes, what it tends to cost, the signs you can see in your own records, and the controls that prevent most of it without treating everyone as a suspect.

What counts as timesheet fraud

The term covers any time record that the person making it knows is false. You will also see it called time theft or time card fraud. The common forms:

  • Padding hours. Adding ten or fifteen minutes to the start or end of a shift, or logging a full day for a short one.
  • Buddy punching. One person clocks in or out for another.
  • Unrecorded breaks. A long lunch or a personal errand left on the clock.
  • Phantom work. Hours logged against a project or client that nobody worked. In a business that bills by the hour, this becomes overbilling the client.
  • Editing after the fact. Changing old entries once nobody is looking at that week any more.
  • Shaving time. The same thing in the other direction: a manager trimming someone’s recorded hours to avoid overtime. This is falsifying a time record too, and it is the employer who answers for it.

A mistake is not fraud. Someone who forgets to stop a timer, or books Tuesday’s work to the wrong project, has made an error. What separates the two is intent and pattern. The same “mistake” every week, always in the same person’s favor, is no longer a mistake.

What it costs

There are no reliable figures for everyday padding, because most of it is never found. The best data is on cases that were serious enough to be investigated. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners publishes a study of those cases every two years. According to PayrollOrg’s summary of the 2026 edition, payroll fraud schemes ran for a median of 13 months before they were discovered, and cost $4,800 a month on average while they lasted. The same summary calls falsified timesheets and time clock entries “one of the easiest and most common types of payroll fraud”.

Two things stand out. The weekly amounts are small, which is why they go unnoticed. And the time to discovery is long: thirteen months is more than fifty weekly timesheets, each of which somebody approved.

Signs you can see in your records

None of these proves anything. Each one is a reason to look, and then to ask.

What you seeWhat it can meanThe innocent explanation
The same start and end time every day, to the minuteTimes typed in afterwards, not recorded as they happenedA fixed shift, entered honestly from the schedule
A whole week entered on Friday afternoonHours rebuilt from memory, usually rounded upA busy week and a bad habit
Two people clocking in seconds apart, every dayOne person clocking in for bothThey share a ride to work
Overtime that appears only when the supervisor is awayPadded hoursWork that really does pile up then
Old entries changed after the week was closedHours adjusted once nobody is checkingA genuine correction
Long entries with no project or descriptionTime that cannot be tied to any workA timer left running overnight

Seven controls that prevent most of it

1. Write the rules down

Say what counts as work time, how breaks are recorded, whether times are rounded and how, and who may change an entry afterwards. Most padding lives in the gaps a policy never covered. If you round, round both ways. US federal rules allow rounding to the nearest 5 minutes, tenth or quarter of an hour only if, over time, people are still paid for all the time they actually worked.

2. Record time as it happens

A timer or a time clock records the moment. A timesheet filled in on Friday records a guess. The further the record is from the work, the more it drifts, and it rarely drifts down.

3. Make people prove who they are at a shared clock

Buddy punching only works when anyone can clock in as anyone. A personal PIN stops the casual version. A personal QR code, or a photo taken at each clock-in, stops most of the rest. Tell people what is recorded and why.

One person's kiosk screen with totals for today and this week, and the Clock in and Start break buttons.
A shared time clock where each person clocks in under their own name. This one is a Punchly kiosk.

4. Approve every week, then lock it

Have a manager who knows the work look at each person’s week and approve it. Once a week is approved, close it to changes. A scheme that runs for thirteen months has passed through more than fifty approvals, so the approval has to be a real look and not a click.

5. Check the exceptions, not every line

Nobody can read every entry. Look for the odd ones instead: entries with no project, entries shorter than a minute or longer than a normal shift, and entries that overlap.

The Time audit panel with checks: without project, without task, missing required fields, shorter than and longer than.
An exceptions check: only the entries with something odd about them, each marked with the reason.

6. Keep a record of changes

When an entry is changed, you should be able to see who changed it, when, and what it said before. This protects honest employees as much as it protects the company.

7. Keep monitoring in proportion

Screenshots and location records can settle a dispute. They can also wreck trust. Use them where the risk justifies it, switch them on openly, and say so in the policy.

What to put in a timekeeping policy

Most of the controls above only work if they are written down where everyone can read them. A timekeeping policy does not need to be long. It needs to answer these questions.

  • What counts as work time? Travel between sites, setting up, clearing down and training all need a yes or a no.
  • How are breaks recorded, and which of them are paid?
  • How is time recorded, and by when must a week be complete?
  • Is time rounded? If so, to what, and in both directions.
  • Who can change an entry afterwards, and is the change recorded?
  • Who approves each person’s time, and what happens when the approver is away?
  • What is monitored? Say plainly if photos, screenshots or location are in use, when, and who can see them.
  • What happens when a record is found to be false?

Have each person read it when they join, and again whenever it changes. A rule nobody was told about is hard to enforce, and harder to defend.

What to do when you suspect it

  1. Check the records first. Compare the timesheet with what else you know: the schedule, the clock records, the work that was delivered.
  2. Ask before you accuse. Most odd entries have a dull explanation.
  3. Pay for the time that was actually worked. Correct a record only when you can show it is wrong. In the US, employers must keep accurate records of the hours worked each day, and must pay for work they allowed to happen even if nobody asked for it: an employer, the rule says, “cannot sit back and accept the benefits without compensating for them”. Docking pay as a punishment is a different thing from correcting a false entry, and it is where employers get into trouble.
  4. Close the gap that allowed it. If one person could do it, others can.
  5. Write down what you found and what you did.

This is general information, not legal advice. Wage and hour rules differ by country and by state. Talk to an employment lawyer before you deduct pay or dismiss someone.

How Punchly handles each control

Punchly is time tracking software, so here is plainly what it does about each of the controls above, and the plan each one needs.

ControlIn PunchlyPlan
Time recorded as it happensA timer on the web, desktop and phone, and a kiosk on a shared tabletFree; kiosk on Standard
Timer only, no typed timesForce timer switches off typing or editing times by handPro
Proof of identity at the clockA PIN or a personal QR code for each person, and a photo at each clock-in if you chooseStandard; photos on Pro
No double entriesAllow, warn about or block two entries by one person at the same timeFree
Weekly approvalSubmit, approve or reject a week. An approved week is read-only for everyoneStandard
Closing the pastA lock date that can move forward by itself every week or monthStandard
ExceptionsTime audit lists entries with no project, or shorter or longer than a length you setBasic
Record of changesAn audit log of who changed what, when, and the value beforeEnterprise

Punchly does not check anyone’s face automatically. Kiosk photos are there for a manager to look at, and they are deleted after the period you choose. Screenshots and location are optional and off until an admin switches them on.

Questions people ask

It is falsifying a time record, which breaks nearly every employer’s rules and can be grounds for dismissal. Whether it is also a crime depends on where you are and how much money is involved. Ask a lawyer before treating it as one.

No, if it is done evenly. US federal rules allow rounding to the nearest 5 minutes, tenth or quarter of an hour as long as it does not, over time, leave people unpaid for time they worked. Rounding that only ever favors the employer fails that test.

You do not owe pay for hours that were not worked, but you need evidence before you change a record, and you still owe everything that was worked. Deducting pay as a penalty is a separate matter and is restricted in many places.

Three things cover most of it: record time as it happens, have one person approve each week, and lock the week afterwards. Monitoring tools are for the cases those three do not solve.

See approvals, the lock date and the kiosk in a free workspace

Punchly is free for teams of up to 5. Every new workspace gets 7 days of the Pro features, with no credit card.